Interdisciplinary Approach to Health Services Provision: Russian Practices in Expert Assessments in Palliative Care Case
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.36683/ee241.39-48Keywords:
interdisciplinary approach, palliative care, health services quality, non-governmental providers of social services, socially oriented non-profit organizationsAbstract
Public innovations in the development of palliative care within the framework of an interdisciplinary approach introduced by the Federal Law № 18-FZ dated 06.03.2019 "On Amendments to the Federal Law "On the Basics of Public Health Protection in the Russian Federation" on palliative care" require expert assessments, which determines the relevance of the research topic and goal setting - to describe the state and identify changes in the organization of palliative care in the Russian Federation in expert assessments in connection with the introduced public innovations. The research methods are: secondary analysis of foreign model of palliative care organization and longitudinal study with the method of expert assessments of 2017, 2023. The results of the study are as follows. Firstly, it is revealed that under modern conditions, interdisciplinary approach is becoming a methodological basis for ensuring health systems sustainability. Secondly, the results of longitudinal study show that introduced public innovations in transformation of the Russian palliative care model increase expert assessments to satisfactory positioning concerning most components of palliative care organization, which was characterized as "very low" and "low" in 2017. Thirdly, such a component as "exemption from work for persons caring for a seriously ill family member (sick leave for care)", which received low expert ratings, is the growing point in the organizational model of palliative care.Downloads
References
Паллиативная помощь как сфера междисциплинарного взаимодействия: от теории к практике / Н. С. Григорьева
С. И. Колесников
В. Ю. Кулькова [и др.]. – Москва : Ленанд
2021. – 400 с. –
ISBN 978-5-9710-8734-2. – EDN JBBRSY.
Григорьева
Н. С. Стандартизация в системе паллиативной помощи. Междисциплинарная
модель / Н. С. Григорьева // Стандарты и качество. – 2023. – № 1. – С. 52-57. – DOI 10.35400/0038-9692-
2023-1-202-22. – EDN ZUOHAI.
Кулькова
В. Ю. Организационный механизм взаимодействия государства и некоммерческих
организаций в оказании паллиативной помощи / В. Ю. Кулькова // Вопросы управления. – 2018. – № 2(51). – С. 97-102. – EDN XZLEUH.
Кулькова
В. Ю. Организация оказания паллиативной помощи: Российские практики в контексте зарубежного опыта / В. Ю. Кулькова // Менеджмент в России и за рубежом. – 2018. – № 3. – С.
48-58. – EDN UTNHGY.
Кулькова
В. Ю. Некоммерческие организации в предоставлении услуг в сфере здравоохранения на государственном и региональном уровнях / В. Ю. Кулькова // Государственное управление.
Электронный вестник. – 2022. – № 95. – С. 81-92. – DOI 10.24412/2070-1381-2022-95-81-92. – EDN
VCDWZX.
Чубарова
Т. В. Задачи законодательного регулирования системы паллиативной помощи в
Российской Федерации // Аналитический вестник. – Москва : Издание Государственной Думы
2018. –
С. 8-10.
Шелякин
В. А. Частные медицинские организации в системе ОМС: преимущества для пациента и риски для государственной лечебной сети / В. А. Шелякин
А. С. Худяев // Обязательное медицинское страхование в Российской Федерации. – 2020. – № 3. – С. 20-25. – EDN NGYOHT.
Шестакова
Е. Е. Организация и финансирование длительного ухода за престарелыми: опыт
стран ОЭСР / Е. Е. Шестакова // Управление здравоохранением. – 2015. – № 3(45). – С. 109-122. – EDN
VZCMGX.
Задачи законодательного регулирования системы паллиативной помощи в Российской Федерации: отчет НИР / Институт экономики РАН
рук. Т.В. Чубарова. – Москва
2017. – 329 с. – № госрегистрации 0173100009617000077.
Участие НКО в оказании услуг в социальной сфере (Специальный доклад Общественной
палаты Российской Федерации) / Общественная палата Российской Федерации
сост. и общ. ред. Е. А.
Тополева-Солдунова
Е. Г. Орлова
О. В. Коротеева [и др.]. – Москва : Современные информационные
системы
2019. – 96 с.
Chubarova
T. International knowledge transfer and Russian social policy: The case of gender
mainstreaming / T. Chubarova
N. Grigorieva // Global Social Policy. – 2021. – Vol. 21
No. 1. – P. 96-116. –
DOI 10.1177/1468018120969325. – EDN WVMMMU.
Council of Europe. Recommendation Rec (2003) 24 of the Committee of Ministers to member
states on the organisation of palliative care // Council of Europe
2003. – URL:
www.coe.int/t/dg3/health/Source/Rec(2003)24_en.pdf (last accessed: 21.01.2024).
Glaeser E.
Shleifer A. Non-for-profit Enterprise // NBER Working Paper 6810
1998.
How many people are in need of palliative care worldwide? // Global atlas of palliative care at the
end of life. – Geneva: World Health Organization and Worldwide Palliative Care Alliance
2014.
List R. Global Civi Society. An Overview. Johns Hopkins University Press
2003.
National Academies of Sciences
Engineering
and Medicine. Disaster Resilience: A National Imperative. Washington
DC: The National Academies Press
2012. – URL: https://doi.org/10.17226/13457.
National Consensus Project for Quality Palliative Care. Clinical Practice Guidelines for Quality
Palliative Care
2004.
Rose-Ackerman S. Altruism
Non-profits
and Economic Theory //Journal of Economic Literature
1996
34 (2). P 701-728.
Salamon L. The Tools of Government: A Guide to the New Governance. New York: Oxford University Press
2002.
Salamon L. New Frontiers of Philanthropy. New York
USA: Oxford University Press
2014. –
234 р.
Smaggus A
Long JC
Ellis LA
Clay-Williams R
Braithwaite J. Government actions and their
relation to resilience in healthcare during the COVID-19 pandemic in New South Wales
Australia and Ontario
Canada // J Health Policy Manag. 2022. 11(9). P. 1682-1694. – doi:10.34172/ijhpm.2021.67.
Ready for the Next Crisis? Investing in Health System Resilience
OECD Health Policy Studies.
ОECD Publishing
Paris
2023. – URL: https://doi.org/10.1787/1e53cf80-en.
Towards an Integrated Health Information System in Korea. ОECD Publishing
Paris
2023. –
URL: https://doi.org/10.1787/c4e6c88d-en.
24.Edelman (2022). Trust Barometer: cycle of distrust. – URL: https://www.edelman.com/trust/2022-
trust-barometer (last accessed 21.01. 2024).
Weisbrod B. The Non-profit Economy. Harvard University Press
1988.
Worth M. Nonprofit Management: Principles and Practice. Los Angeles
L.
New Delhi
Singapore
Washington: SAGE
2009. P.33-40.
Work – life balance measures for persons of working age with dependent relatives in Europe. A
study of national policies // European Social Policy Network ESPN. 2016.
Grigoreva N.S.
Kolesnikov S.I.
Kulkova V.Yu.
Chubarova T.V.
Sharova M.A.
Shestakova E.E.
(2021). Interdisciplinary interaction to palliative care: from theory to practice. Moskva: LENAND. – 400 р.
Grigoreva N.S. (2023). Standardization in the system of palliative care. Interdisciplinary model.
Standards and Quality [Standarty i kachestvo]. Vol. 1. pp. 52-57.
Kulkova V.YU. (2018a). Organizational mechanism of interaction between the state and non-profit
organizations in the provision of palliative care. Management Issues [Voprosy upravleniya]. Vol 2 (51). pp.
36-46
Kulkova V.YU. (2018b). Organization of palliative care: Russian practices in the context of foreign
experience. Management in Russia and abroad [Menedzhment v Rossii i za rubezhom]. Vol. 3. pp. 48-58
Kulkova V.YU. (2022). Non-commercial organizations in the provision of healthcare services at the
state and regional levels. Public administration. Electronic Bulletin [Gosudarstvennoe upravlenie. Elektronnyi
vestnik]. vol. 95. pp. 81-92
Chubarova T.V. (2018). Objectives of legislative regulation of the palliative care system in the
Russian Federation. Analytical bulletin. Moskva: Publication of the State Duma
2018. – P. 8-10
Sheljakin V. A.
Hudjakv A.S. (2020). Private medical organizations in the CHI system: benefits
for the patient and risks for the state medical network Compulsory health insurance in the Russian Federation
[Objazatel'noe medicinskoe strahovanie v Rossijskoj Federacii]. Vol. 3. pp. 20-25.
Shestakova E.E. (2015). Organization and financing of long-term care for the elderly: the experience
of OECD countries. Health management [Upravlenie zdravookhraneniem]. Vol. 3(45). pp. 109-122
Tasks of legislative regulation of the system of palliative care in the Russian Federation: NIR report
/ Institute of Economics of the Russian Academy of Sciences (2017)
hands T.V. Chubarova. M. 329 p. - State
registration number 0173100009617000077
Participation of NGOs in the provision of services in the social sphere (Special report of the Civic
Chamber of the Russian Federation) / Civic Chamber of the Russian Federation (2019)
comp. and general
ed. E.A. Topoleva-Soldunova
E.G. Orlova
O.V. Koroteeva
A.M. Spivak
R.M. Olkhovsky
A.A. Vavilov
V.B. Benevolensky. M.: "Modern information systems" [M.: «Sovremennye informatsionnye sistemy»]. 96 p.
Chubarova T.
Grigorieva N. International knowledge transfer and russian social policy: the case
of gender mainstreaming //Global Social Policy. 2021. Vol. 21. № 1. p. 96-116
Council of Europe. Recommendation Rec (2003) 24 of the Committee of Ministers to member
states on the organisation of palliative care// Council of Europe. 2003. URL:
www.coe.int/t/dg3/health/Source/Rec(2003)24_en.pdf (last accessed 21.01.2024).
Glaeser E.
Shleifer A. Non-for-profit Enterprise // NBER Working Paper 6810
1998
How many people are in need of palliative care worldwide? In: Global atlas of palliative care at
the end of life. Geneva: World Health Organization and Worldwide Palliative Care Alliance
2014
List R. Global Civi Society. An Overview. Johns Hopkins University Press
2003
National Academies of Sciences
Engineering
and Medicine. Disaster Resilience: A National Imperative. Washington
DC: The National Academies Press
2012. https://doi.org/10.17226/13457.
National Consensus Project for Quality Palliative Care. Clinical Practice Guidelines for Quality
Palliative Care
2004.
Rose- Ackerman S. Altruism
Non-profits
and Economic Theory //Journal of Economic Literature
1996
34 (2). pp. 701-728
Salamon L. The Tools of Government: A Guide to the New Governance. New York: Oxford
University Press
2002
Salamon L. New Frontiers of Philanthropy / L. Salamon / New York
USA: Oxford University
Press
2014. – 234 р.
Smaggus A
Long JC
Ellis LA
Clay-Williams R
Braithwaite J. Government actions and their
relation to resilience in healthcare during the COVID-19 pandemic in New South Wales
Australia and Ontario
Canada // J Health Policy Manag. 2022. 11(9). pp. 1682–1694. doi:10.34172/ijhpm.2021.67
Ready for the Next Crisis? Investing in Health System Resilience
OECD Health Policy Studies.
ОECD Publishing
Paris
2023. https://doi.org/10.1787/1e53cf80-en.
Towards an Integrated Health Information System in Korea. ОECD Publishing
Paris
2023.
https://doi.org/10.1787/c4e6c88d-en
24.Edelman (2022). Trust Barometer: cycle of distrust. Available at: https://www.edelman.com/trust/2022-trust-barometer (last accessed 21.01.2024).
Weisbrod B. The Non-profit Economy. Harvard University Press
1988.
Worth M. Nonprofit Management: Principles and Practice. Los Angeles
L.
New Delhi
Singapore
Washington: SAGE
2009. pp..33-40.
Work – life balance measures for persons of working age with dependent relatives in Europe. A
study of national policies // European Social Policy Network ESPN. 2016.
